No printed Shake Shack secret menu exists at the counter, but regulars still build nine off-menu combinations by describing them to staff. Smoke Shack Quad Burger and Bacon Grilled Cheese Sandwich are two of the better-known requests.
Each build rings up as the item it starts from, and the tables below show that base price and calorie count. Describing the base item and the swap is enough to get it built right.
The short answer
The Shake Shack secret menu covers nine off-menu builds, each one modifying a burger, hot dog, fries order or shake already on the printed board. The Smoke Shack Quad Burger stacks four patties on one bun, and Beer Float pairs frozen custard with a beer of choice. Each one rings up at the price of its base item, from $4.49 for a scoop of Frozen Custard to $9.99 for a SmokeShack.
At a glance
9
Off-menu hacks sourced
3
Item groups
4
Burger Rebuilds
2
Hot Dog and Fries Swaps
3
Shake, Beer and Custard Mashups
7
FAQ questions answered
Shake Shack Secret Menu Items
Nine off-menu builds make up this list, each one showing up often enough across ordering guides to track by name. Every build starts from an item already on the printed board. A swapped bun, an added topping or a specific beer pairing is usually all it takes.
Burger Rebuilds at Shake Shack
The Smoke Shack Quad Burger, Bacon Grilled Cheese Sandwich, Onion and Pickle Shackburger and Bunless Shack Burger all rework a build already on the board. All four count among the most requested off-menu builds. Smoke Shack Quad Burger goes furthest of the four, stacking four patties onto a single SmokeShack instead of one. Bunless Shack Burger drops the bun entirely, swapping in a lettuce wrap for a lower-carb build.
| Item | How to Order | Base Price | Base Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Smoke Shack Quad Burger | Ask for four burger patties on a SmokeShack instead of one, or order it by name at the register. | $9.99 | 570 |
| Bacon Grilled Cheese Sandwich | Order it by name, or ask for crispy bacon to be added to a regular Grilled Cheese. | $4.99 | 320 |
| Onion and Pickle Shackburger | Ask for sliced onion and pickle added to a regular ShackBurger, or request just one of the two toppings. | $7.79 | 500 |
| Bunless Shack Burger | Ask for any burger bunless, or request a lettuce wrap in place of the potato bun. | $7.79 | 330 |
Hot Dog and Fries Swaps at Shake Shack
Garden Dog and Sport Pepper Cheese Fries both rework an item already sold at the counter. Both count among the simpler builds on this list. Garden Dog swaps the sausage itself for a pickle, then piles on tomato, cucumber and onion. Sport Pepper Cheese Fries takes a simpler route, folding chopped sport peppers into a regular order of Cheese Fries.
| Item | How to Order | Base Price | Base Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Garden Dog | Ask for a classic hot dog with a pickle standing in for the sausage, topped with chopped tomato, cucumber and diced white onion. | $4.99 | 350 |
| Sport Pepper Cheese Fries | Ask for chopped sport peppers added to an order of Cheese Fries. | $5.99 | 710 |
Shake, Beer and Custard Mashups at Shake Shack
Shake Shack Shandy, Shake Shack Style Ice Cream Sandwich and Beer Float each pair a Shake Shack staple with something extra. That extra comes from the bar or the custard machine. Shandy mixes a Fifty/Fifty lemonade with beer in place of the iced-tea half. Beer Float goes simpler still, dropping a scoop of vanilla frozen custard into a beer of choice.
| Item | How to Order | Base Price | Base Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shake Shack Shandy | Order it by name, or ask for a Fifty/Fifty lemonade with the iced-tea half swapped for a beer of choice. | $3.99 | 160 |
| Shake Shack Style Ice Cream Sandwich | Ask for a scoop of frozen custard served between two toasted potato buns. | $4.49 | 280 |
| Beer Float | Ask for a scoop of vanilla frozen custard added to a beer of choice. | $4.49 | 280 |
Shake Shack Secret Menu FAQs
About the author
Sophia W. Steadham writes MenuQuill. She is a food blogger and restaurant review expert who has spent years eating her way through American chain menus, from small-town drive-thrus to national roll-outs.